Previous Comments

[1] On Apr-19-2006, Nathan wrote:

Awesome. It's great to see that film get some positive attention. I know there are many who disagree with me, but I think it's a brilliant book-to-film adaptation.

That list is a pretty good one. I seldom agree with the entries on such lists, but there are lots of films on there I agree are some of the best book-to-film adaptations. It's criminal, though, that "The Shining" was omitted. It's a decent book; it's a masterpiece of a film.

[2] On Apr-20-2006, anssi wrote:

Notable absentee: Requiem for a Dream.

[3] On Apr-20-2006, Settemod wrote:

Ok, kill me: I don't like Am.Psy.- the movie. The book is one of the greatest book of the century (yeah). The movie it's just... bah.

[4] On Apr-27-2006, wrote:

25th Hour?

Ok, some people probably find it boring, but I think it's very well-adapted. Both the book and the movie are good, with the book slightly superior.

[5] On Apr-27-2006, JGold wrote:

American Psycho's on the list but Rules of Attraction isn't? Even Ellis himself thinks that parts of that movie were better than his book! Although I am happy to see GoodFellas, Fight Club, and Trainspotting made the cut...